The Internet seems to be having one of its periodic cycles of wank about fanfic -- or maybe it's always there and I only notice it periodically -- so this would probably be a good time to mention that I used to be anti-fanfic (and personally squicked by the idea of people writing about my characters), but no longer am. I've seen people pointing out that my original feelings on the matter were rendered pretty hypocritical by the publication of Plastic Jesus, and they are right. I wrote Plastic Jesus during a spell of creative bankruptcy and am not proud of the book (except for the illustration of Amsterdam -- I wish I had the original of that). If I had it to do over again, I wouldn't publish it. (Not to take anything away from readers who enjoyed it; I've learned that one should always appreciate enjoyment of one's work. Took me a while, but I think I've got it now.)
It's not so much about Plastic Jesus, though; it's just about getting older and encountering real troubles and realizing that, as
theferrett eloquently pointed out today, people being inspired by your characters and wanting to play in your world is a pretty goddamn luxurious "problem" to have. It doesn't matter, it doesn't do harm, and the loss-of-copyright bugaboos that scared a bunch of authors (including me) some years back appear to have been inaccurately reported and (probably) wildly exaggerated. So I hereby apologize to everyone I've ever been a douchenozzle to about fanfic. I hope I wasn't too much of one; I know I've expressed some very cranky general opinions, but I don't think I've ever actually been mean to anyone who wrote/wanted to write about my characters. (I imagine the volume of PZB fanfic is minuscule compared to most fandoms anyway.) I still don't want to actually read it, but obviously the world has moved on in regards to this issue and my attitude needs to catch up or else I will only needlessly insult readers or would-be readers. The FAQ on my website does not reflect this change in attitude because I'm a lazy bum who never updates my website, but the next time I do, it will.
It's not so much about Plastic Jesus, though; it's just about getting older and encountering real troubles and realizing that, as

Comments
Because I'm on my tenth volume of stories...
Edited at 2010-05-08 11:13 pm (UTC)
That may be why I got reminded of Stephen King's "Dollar babies," the short films he's allowed of his short stories; King admitted his lawyer didn't like the idea. I was wondering why this was bringing that to mind, because it's not at all a related issue, as it's translation from one medium to another instead of straight writing-in-another-writer's-world. I've seen a few of them: the one standout being, not surprisingly, Frank Darabont's "The Woman in the Room."
I'm glad most of the fanfic writers I know are both A) very aware of the pitfalls that worry a lot of authors about fanfic and B) write original stuff too. Writing just fanfic seems a non-fulfilling thing.
In terms of my contributions being picked up, I had a character name used in one of their sourcebooks and I contributed some background research for a serious game system rewrite in their latest edition. My "royalties" were in getting a system that didn't suck :-)
Nowadays, I'm writing for a completely new (computer game) setting. I think if fanfic turns up of anything that I write, that'll be a positive sign. Not sure quite how I'd feel about someone deriving a commercial work from it, though.
(Perfumer, are you out there? I'd like to link to you, but I lost most of my links when I switched browsers.)
Searching for such things via Google, I can't find the perfumer in question. It's not someone like Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab though, is it? I hear they do some character-themed scents.
If you ever dig that link up, I would love to see it.
I recently read an interview with the author of Brokeback Mountain in which she related all the awful fanfic she received and how horrified she was by people telling her they thought they were 'fixing' her story by writing different endings. I can see why that would irritate the creator, although I found it funny people thought she'd react positively towards somebody else fixing her fiction.
Even I've felt that impulse occasionally (the one moment that comes to mind was seeing the first Mission: Impossible film and wondering if there were bigger, deeper reasons for Mr. Phelps to have gotten disenchanted), but I'd do that just as an exercise, not as something to go "Hey! Author person! You did that wrong! Here it is all fix-ed-er!"
Issue six of Sandman is kind of about that pitfall, with the waitress concocting her stories in which she makes the lives of her customers conform to what she thinks their lives should be. And yep, now it's even clearer to me how obnoxious that is.
If they stumble upon it fine, but don't leaaad them to fandom and don't shove it in their faces :/ Rude people are rude.
I never did do it, but if I do I wonder if you'd like to have a look at it.
- Mel
I've seen all different types of reactions to fanfiction, from Naoko Takeuchi ("Send me some!") to Anne Rice (OMGWTFNO), and I always thought that your original stance on fanfiction, while it stung a little, was classy and well thought out. I think this one is, too. Thanks again!
All I know, I used to be anti-fanfic too, until my friend sent me an incredibly amazing chapter fanfiction about Bam Margera and Ryan Dunn, bwahahaha.
Anywhat, I just thought I'd comment. I kinda keep my fanfic love secret because a lot of people don't understand it, and I don't even totally understand it... But I love writing about people I'm sure are actually bumpin' uglies in reality.